Control4 vs Savant vs RTi vs Crestron ? We are often asked what the best Smart Home or Home Automation system would be. This summary points out the pros and cons of each system based on our experience and knowledge

Control4

Overview: Control4 is a popular residential control system. It is known for its affordability, reliability, and extensive compatibility with a wide range of hardware. It offers built-in streaming music functionality, providing excellent value without additional costs.

Key Features:

• Value: Control4 delivers high-end automation capabilities at a reasonable cost, making it accessible for those with moderate budgets.
• Implementation Cost: Control4’s programming requires less skill. It utilises a simple drag-and-drop interface that reduces setup time and eliminates the need for specialised programmers. It does however offer some customisability Through special buttons. These can be programmed to offer additional functionality. For Example, this could be a favourite lighting scene or a preset on an amplifier.
• Remotes: The new Control4’s Halo Remotes, have proven to be a step forward for client features and ease of use. These now feature back lit hard buttons.

Drawbacks:

• Compatibility: Control4 integrates well with its own ecosystem. However, compatibility with third-party products, such as Lutron lighting and shading systems, can be inconsistent. This issue is often due to drivers or their updates.
• Ease of Use: The user interface is fixed and requires multiple steps for certain actions, with limited customisation options.
• Warranty: Limited Warranty runs for a period of two years from the date that the Customer purchases from an authorised Control4 dealer.
• Life Span: Typically, a Control 4 system has a working lifespan of around 5 years. This is similar to a high-quality computer etc, after which it may need updating

Savant

Overview: Savant is renowned for its excellent user experience, especially when integrated with Apple devices. It offers high-quality hardware and the ability to create customised scenes for audio, video, lighting, and environmental settings.

Key Features:

• User Experience: The Pro Remote X2 is a standout, offering a responsive touchscreen and multi-room control capabilities.
• Multi-Zone Audio: Savant’s AVB-powered audio technology provides flexible, high-quality audio distribution throughout the home.

Drawbacks:

• Compatibility: Savant’s system works best with fully supported Savant drivers, limiting compatibility with some third-party products. New drivers can be written, however, this can take time and incur additional costs.
• Cost: Savant is more expensive than Control4, with hardware costs similar to Crestron. The need for less programming skill can be a deciding factor for some installers.
• Ease of Use: The app is visually appealing but less intuitive, and the user interface lacks the customisability offered by other systems.
• Warranty: Limited Warranty is for two years from the date that the Customer purchases from an authorised dealer
• Life Span: Typically a Savant system has a working lifespan of around 5-10  years. This is better than a high-quality computer etc, after which it may need updating

RTi (Remote Technologies Incorporated)

Overview: RTi is known for its versatile and flexible control systems that cater to residential and commercial applications. RTi focuses on providing highly customisable solutions with a strong emphasis on user interface design. Additionally, it’s ease of integration with various third-party systems.

Key Features:

• Customization: RTi systems are highly customisable, allowing for tailored solutions that meet specific user needs. This flexibility extends to both hardware and software.
• Integration: RTi excels in integrating with a wide range of third-party systems. Such as AV equipment, lighting, climate control, and security systems.
• User Interfaces: RTi offers a variety of user interfaces These include touchscreens, handheld remotes, keypads, and mobile apps. All are designed for intuitive operation.
• Warranty: Limited Warranty runs for three years from the date that the Customer purchases from an authorised dealer

Drawbacks:

• Programming: RTi programming can be complex and typically requires professional installation to ensure optimal performance. The programming environment is less user-friendly compared to Control4.
• Cost: RTi offers a range of products at different price points. The cost can add up depending on the level of customisation and the number of integrated devices.
• Support: RTi relies heavily on professional installers and integrators for support. This can be a disadvantage for users seeking more DIY-friendly solutions.
• Life Span: Typically an RTi system has a working lifespan of around 5-10  years. This is better than a high-quality computer etc, after which it may need updating

Crestron

Overview: Crestron is a dominant force in the corporate and residential control systems market. It offers unparalleled customisation and powerful programming capabilities, therefore, ideal for large and complex installations. Crestron delivers a solution for virtually every requirement

Key Features:

• Video Distribution: Crestron NVX and DMX video switching are industry-leading, providing superior functionality for advanced video needs.
• Remotes: Crestron’s handheld interfaces rival the Savant Pro X2, with the added benefit of custom programming for enhanced functionality.
• Warranty: Crestron provides extended warranty coverage of 3 to 5 years, depending on the component.
• Client Experience: Custom programming allows for immediate resolution of compatibility issues, reducing the teething problems often associated with new systems.
• Life Span: Typically a Crestron system has a working lifespan of around 10-15 years, outperforming its competition, saving upgrade costs

Drawbacks:

• Cost: Crestron is the most expensive option due to its high-quality hardware and the extensive programming required.
• Programming Time: Despite in-house programming capabilities, the complexity and time needed to program Crestron systems are greater than those for Control4 or Savant.

Our Conclusion to the Control4 vs Savant vs RTi vs Crestron Question

• Control4 is ideal for those seeking a cost-effective, reliable system with good hardware compatibility and a straightforward setup.
• Savant offers an excellent user experience, particularly for Apple users. With high-quality hardware but overall at a higher cost, with some compatibility limitations.
• RTi provides a highly customisable and versatile solution with strong integration capabilities. It will require professional programming and can be more expensive depending on the level of customisation.
• Crestron is the best choice for large, complex installations requiring extensive customisation. With superior video distribution, despite its higher cost and longer programming times. Its long lifespan is also a major benefit as systems need less upgrading over time. The Additional warranty is also an advantage. Often, products are purchased around a year before clients move into their new homes, sometimes even longer.
• Market Share: Despite the price, Crestron Enjoys a substantial lead in its revenues. Its revenues are $850 Million, with Control4 at $98 Million and Savant $135 Million
• Factory Support: As Crestron has such a dominance in the market, they invest in world-class support. When there are challenges there is no one better.

We hope or Control4 vs Savant vs RTi vs Crestron comparison is helpful. Each system has its strengths and weaknesses. Our advice would be that the best choice depends on the specific needs and budget of the user.

*Source https://growjo.com/company/Crestron